In June, a petition was filed in New York Supreme Court to prevent the construction of an eight-story hotel next door to the historic Merchant’s House Museum in the East Village. Now, Curbed reports, the proposal to build the hotel was unanimously rejected Thursday by the City Council’s subcommittee on zoning and franchises. The 186-year-old townhouse belonged to hardware merchant Seabury Tredwell, who bought the 10,000-square-foot residence for $18,000 in 1832.
The museum, which has been remarkably preserved since then, became the first property in Manhattan to be designated a New York City landmark in 1965. But landmark status does not guarantee protection from any adjacent construction projects. The museum began legal action against the hotel project because, the museum argued, construction would have destroyed the building.
The no vote represents a big setback for Kalodop II Park Corp, who is behind the proposal. After the hotel proposal was unanimously nixed by the community board in June, the museum filed a lawsuit against the City Planning Commission and the project’s developer on the grounds that the danger posed by construction was not outlined adequately.
The proposal heads to the full City Council next week. Council Member Carlina Rivera, who represents the museum’s district, said her priority was to ensure the protection for the museum, but that she was willing to discuss options with the developers. As council members generally side with the corresponding district on neighborhood matters, it’s not likely that other council members will oppose her position. Rivera said: “We believe this proposal goes too far.”
The hotel had, in fact, been approved in 2014 by the Landmarks Preservation Commission, though commissioners called the proposal “drab on so many levels.” Kalodop owns the parking garage next to the museum and is applying for an amendment to the city zoning code to get a special permit for constructing the hotel in a historic district.
- Merchant’s House Museum files petition in court against construction of adjacent eight-story hotel
- NYC’s 10 best historic house museums
- Preservationists, LGBT groups push Landmarks to designate Walt Whitman’s Clinton Hill home
Tags : 29 east 4th Street, City Council, Merchant's House Museum, NYC landmarks
Neighborhoods : East Village