Santiago Calatrava ‘Treated Like a Dog’ After WTC Transportation Hub Takes a Toll on His Reputation

Posted On Wed, May 20, 2015 By

Posted On Wed, May 20, 2015 By In People, Starchitecture

Starchitect Santiago Calatrava has taken a media beating for the World Trade Center Transportation Hub, the long-delayed (it’s nearly six years off schedule), incredibly-over-budget (final construction costs ring in around $4 billion, twice what was projected, making it the world’s most expensive train station), flying bird-looking (though some critics think it looks more like a “rack of lamb”) PATH station project that he designed as part of the WTC revitalization. It was recently announced that the hub would open next month, but as it comes to a close, Santiago Calatrava is stuck at a dead end, noting that the project has taken a major toll on his reputation.

After living in NYC for 12 years, Calatrava has stopped being commissioned for work in the U.S. “I could not compete because people have not asked me to compete,” he told the Wall Street Journal in an interview at his Park Avenue townhouse. “I have been treated like a dog.”

Calatrava wtc transportation hub

Calatrava, considered a “neo-futuristic architect,” has designed such renowned projects as the sports complex for the 2004 Athens summer Olympics, the Liège-Guillemins railway station in Belgium, and the Alamillo Bridge in Seville, Spain. He’s also the architect behind the Ground Zero Church, another site in the World Trade Center area. But despite these international commissions, in recent years Calatrava has gained a reputation for designing projects that run over schedule and have exceedingly high costs, mostly thanks to the high-profile controversy at the WTC Transportation Hub, but also due in part to other projects like the cultural center he designed in his hometown in Valencia, Spain, which went hundreds of millions of dollars over budget and required hefty repairs.

In reference to the PATH station, the Journal explains, “The reasons are numerous, but broadly its problems can be found in the interconnected nature of the project, which weaves through a complex site densely packed with office towers, an underground museum and retail, numerous officials involved with the project said. With two train lines running throughout construction, it has also proved a logistical nightmare.” Plus, the 16-acre site is owned by the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, an agency known for delayed projects and loss of revenue.

Calatrava WTC Transportation Hub Oculus

Clearly, Calatrava feels the scarlet letter he’s received is very unfair, especially since he says he was never consulted about the cost and scheduling for the project. When he was hired for the job, the city was still reeling from 9/11, and state officials wanted an anchor for lower Manhattan similar to Grand Central. Elihu Rubin, an architectural historian at Yale University, told the Journal, “It was the kind of environment that inspired grand visions. The risk for overruns was there from the start. The politics of rebuilding can generate relatively modest cost estimates, when more realistic budgeting would make desirable projects seem out of reach.” As it stands, the hub is made up of 618 steel pieces which weigh more than 12,000 tons, but the architect’s original design was far more intricate and costly, leading Calatrava to believe that the complexity of his design was obvious from the start.

Erica Dumas, a spokeswoman for the Port Authority, gave a curt response to the starchitect’s comments: “While we’re not quite sure what to make of Dr. Calatrava’s musings, the Port Authority is pushing hard to complete the World Trade Center Transportation Hub.”

[Via WSJ]

Transportation Hub rendering and construction photos via Port Authority of NY & NJ

RELATED:

 

Tags : , ,

MOST RECENT ARTICLES

  • Helen Hayes’ former Nyack home asks $719K

    Helen Hayes’ former Nyack home asks $719K

    Helen Hayes‘ acting career spanned nearly 80 years, earning her the nickname “First Lady of American Theatre” and garnering her distinctions ...
  • TBD Architecture designs Tetris-like artist studios for an Upstate couple

    TBD Architecture designs Tetris-like artist studios for an Upstate couple

    TBD Architecture + Design Studio took on the challenge of designing two conjoined artist studios for a couple on the same property ...
  • Contract expires for 44,000 NYC subway and bus workers

    Contract expires for 44,000 NYC subway and bus workers

    After the Transport Workers Union and the MTA failed to reach a deal last night, the contracts expired for 44,000 subway ...
  • The pros and cons of living above a bar; own the Big Apple Circus for $500K

    The pros and cons of living above a bar; own the Big Apple Circus for $500K

    You may get special privileges when you live above a bar, but you’ll likely have to deal with noise and ...
  • In the historic West Village Bank Building, a $3.45M condo boasts a 17-foot window

    In the historic West Village Bank Building, a $3.45M condo boasts a 17-foot window

    This unique condo was designed by and for the renowned international designer Tui Pranich. As the listing says, his principle was that ...
  • ‘Ten & Taller’ exhibition maps the rise of Manhattan’s first skyscrapers from 1874 to 1900

    ‘Ten & Taller’ exhibition maps the rise of Manhattan’s first skyscrapers from 1874 to 1900

    Though it might seem that each recent generation attempts to take credit for the rise of the futuristic “skyscraper,” buildings ...
  • With the rise of ride-hailing apps, daily yellow cab trips fell 27 percent since 2010

    With the rise of ride-hailing apps, daily yellow cab trips fell 27 percent since 2010

    6sqft recently shared analysis that 3,000 ridesharing vehicles could replace the city’s fleet of 13,587 taxis. And while this was more ...
  • Cuomo dubs revised 421-a plan ‘Affordable New York,’ advances new legislation

    Cuomo dubs revised 421-a plan ‘Affordable New York,’ advances new legislation

    A year after the city’s 421-a tax exemption program expired, a new version of the affordable housing incentive is officially moving ...
  • This renovated historic townhouse in Mott Haven is only $800,000

    This renovated historic townhouse in Mott Haven is only $800,000

    File this one under things you won’t find in Brooklyn: This pretty, totally modernized 2,828 square-foot Queen Anne row house ...
  • Massive Greenpoint loft with beamed ceilings wants $4,750/month

    Massive Greenpoint loft with beamed ceilings wants $4,750/month

    There are over 1,700 glorious square feet in this Greenpoint loft, now up for rent at the Pencil Factory building ...
  • Weekly highlights: Top picks from the 6sqft staff

    Weekly highlights: Top picks from the 6sqft staff

    Cuomo announces 750-mile Empire State Trail, a continuous trail connecting NYC to Canada Live in ODA’s new Crown Heights rental ...
  • Natalia Geci’s clever furniture system was inspired by Marie Kondo’s de-cluttering principles

    Natalia Geci’s clever furniture system was inspired by Marie Kondo’s de-cluttering principles

    Like many organizationally challenged folks, Argentinean designer Natalia Geci was inspired by Marie Kondo’s bestselling book “The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up.” Following ...

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTERS

Thank you, your sign-up request was successful!
This email address is already subscribed, thank you!
Please provide a valid email address.
Please complete the CAPTCHA.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later.