If Robert Moses Visited NYC Today, Here’s Where We’d Take Him

May 12, 2015

If you have even the slightest interest in architecture, urban planning, and NYC history, you know Robert Moses. Unforgettably profiled as the “Power Broker” by Robert Caro, Moses was the “master builder” of mid-20th century New York and its environs. He was a larger-than-life character who had very set ways of approaching urban design. He advocated for highways over public transportation (he built 13 expressways through NYC), dense housing towers over low-scale neighborhoods, and communities segregated by race and class over organic, mixed-demographic areas. Of course, there are plenty of much-loved aspects of the city that also came from Moses–Jones Beach, the United Nations, and ten public swimming pools like the one in McCarren Park.

Regardless of your feelings on Robert Moses, though, we can all agree that the city would not be the same without him. But a lot has changed since he lost his post as director of the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority in the mid 1960s and even more so since he passed away in 1981. So we can’t help but wonder what he would think of our fair city in 2015. To have a little fun, we planned a present-day tour for the ghost of Robert Moses.

Don’t ask a Villager if he or she is a Moses fan–the master planner wanted to turn Broome Street into a highway and extend vehicular traffic down Fifth Avenue, right through Washington Square Park, the perfect spot to start our tour. Wouldn’t it be fun to just sit on the fountain with Mr. Moses and take in all the sights, sounds, and hundreds of people having a lovely time in the well-preserved park. And maybe we’d time this for May of next year, during the Jane’s Walk weekend, since we know he was such an adoring fan of Jane Jacobs.

Stuyvesant Town Oval

Next, we’d take a little stroll through the Lower East Side, where Moses’s famous slum clearance was prevalent, and up to 14th Street. To “help” low-income neighborhoods, Robert Moses used eminent domain to raze them and erect tower-in-the-park-style apartment complexes, which we today know have proved woefully ineffective. One of these projects started off with good intentions: Stuyvesant Town was built as affordable housing for WWII veterans. But in order to construct it, a huge group of low-income residents were evicted, and Moses was vocal about not letting black veterans into the complex. Though Stuy Town today no longer has a social cause attached to it, and has seen huge rent increases in recent years, we’re sure Moses would enjoy seeing the diversity of race, class, and age that makes it up now.

Cross Bronx Expressway, Robert Moses
Cross Bronx Expressway under construction (1957-59) via rimador.net

Since Moses’ main goal in bulldozing the city to make way for various transportation projects was to create a more efficient way to move New Yorkers from point A to point B, it seems only fair that we give him the opportunity to commute to work on the Cross Bronx Expressway. Surely he’ll feel satisfied with his decision to devastate the South Bronx neighborhood of Tremont (along with many others) when he’s sitting in two hours of bumper-to-bumper traffic.

While we’re on the subject of the Cross Bronx, how could we not give Moses the chance to take a ride on the Second Avenue Subway? Oh, wait… it got shelved all the way back in 1942 when Moses, then the chairman of the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority, blocked funds from going to the subway so they could support the Cross Bronx. Then in 1954, he did the same thing, this time to get the Major Deegan constructed.

Brooklyn Heights Promenade construction, Brooklyn Queens Expressway
Construction of the BQE and Brooklyn Heights Promenade (a concession since the neighborhood fought the highway) in 1948, via NYC Department of Parks and Recreation 

We couldn’t go all day without eating, so let’s treat the Power Broker to a nice al fresco lunch across from the Brooklyn Queens Expressway, another one of his vehicular infrastructure projects. To connect the two boroughs, Moses ripped through residential neighborhoods instead of taking a more unobstructed path along the East River. Therefore, the busy road is a fixture in many low-scale, otherwise quiet neighborhoods. But who doesn’t like some exhaust fumes with their burger and fries?

NYC bike architecture
Bike lanes via NYCDOT via photopin cc

How about putting Moses to work? We think painting some bike lanes would be the perfect task. In 2012, when the city first rolled out the Citi Bike system, then commissioner of transportation Janette Sadik-Khan was referred to by the Wall Street Journal as “the anti-Robert Moses, an angel sent down by St. Jane (Jacobs) herself to liberate pedestrians and put the automobile in its place.” To be fair, early in his career Moses did incorporate bike lanes in his Circumferential Parkway on Long Island, in Central and Prospect Parks, and along Brooklyn’s Ocean Parkway. But he also infamously refused to include a bike path across the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge for fear of suicides.

Though Moses was so outspoken about his love for the automobile, he didn’t have a drivers license and instead had a hired limo drive him everywhere. We wonder how he’d like Uber? We’d definitely give him a tutorial in the car-service app, and we have a feeling he’d love it.

Robert Moses
Moses with a model of his proposed Brooklyn Battery Bridge in 1939

And speaking of biking, let’s take him on a leisurely cruise through Governor’s Island, the land mass that he once wanted to turn into a giant anchorage to support his proposed Brooklyn Battery Bridge that would’ve taken drivers from Battery Park to Red Hook. We wonder if he’d like Hammock Grove, the various play fields, and the every-changing public art? Or if he’d still advocate for his preferred model of concrete playgrounds next to a highway.

Though we took some jabs at Robert Moses here, it wouldn’t be fair to say he was all bad. In fact, he created more public parks than anyone in the country’s history, so with that, we’d end our tour at Prospect Park, as he halted plans for a highway through this major Brooklyn green space, calling it “one of the world’s craziest ideas.” Similarly, he blocked proposals to fill Gerritsen Creek and to dump trash into the Jamaica Bay and turn it into an industrial port. Another fun fact? The Journal notes that “long before Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s war against Slurpees, Moses banned candy, ice cream and soda from his city playgrounds. He made the children drink fresh milk instead.” In that case, maybe we’d actually end our tour with a kale salad in Park Slope.

Reporting via:

Robert Moses, Pedal Pusher? –Wall Street Journal
5 Things in NYC We Can Blame on Robert Moses – Untapped Cities



Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *