$5.5M ask for renovated Hamilton Heights mansion is a new Harlem record
Get More Info

$5.5M ask for renovated Hamilton Heights mansion is a new Harlem record

March 21, 2017

If this home is, as the listing calls it, “the jewel of this historic neighborhood,” the three-block historic Harlem enclave of Hamilton Terrace is a treasure trove, anchored by the Hamilton Grange home of Alexander Hamilton. Listed at $5,495,000, the limestone and terra cotta mansion at 72 Hamilton Terrace is recognizable by its mansard slate roof punctuated by dormer windows and the original wrought iron fencing that surrounds it. This nearly-5,000-square-foot home offers five stories of newly-renovated modern living, including a finished cellar with restaurant-style bar and a wine cellar. The home’s $5.495 price tag makes it the priciest single-family listing in the neighborhood; if it sells for that much it may be Harlem’s most expensive sale ever.

After two years of renovation what was formerly a church has been restored and updated for 21st-century living. Entering through the foyer, a bright living room with a gas fireplace greets us.

Through tall mahogany pocket doors we find a cozy library with a wet bar and half bath; beyond is the home’s landscaped back yard–one of many spaces primed for entertaining in any season.

The next floor–by now some critics have come to expect an elevator in a renovation this thorough, but, alas, you’ll need to install your own–offers a gourmet kitchen with an expansive marble center island and marble tile backsplash, herringbone wood floors and a chef’s selection of appliances and fixtures. Also here are a dining room and family room with a second gas fireplace.

On the third floor is the master bedroom, a luxurious marble bath with steam shower and radiant heated floors plus a huge walk-in closet, and a guest suite. On the top floor are two more bedrooms, another bath and a spacious laundry room.

A landscaped roof deck offers views of midtown Manhattan.

Not content with four floors of living and entertaining space this unique mansion rocks a fully-finished cellar with a restaurant-style bar, a wine cellar and a billiards table.

Besides the bragging rights to living in Alexander Hamilton’s old neighborhood and windows on three sides (42 of them!) you get the benefit of nine-zone heating and air conditioning and a security system that he most likely had to live without.

[Listing: 72 Hamilton Terrace by Tamara Marotta for Douglas Elliman]


Images courtesy of Douglas Elliman.

Interested in seeing the property in person?

It’s free, with no obligation.

CityRealty Logo

Distinctive Post Form

"*" indicates required fields

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer and for no listing shall the number of bedrooms listed be considered a legal conclusion.

You May Also Like