NYC May Get a Big Ugly Wall Instead of Bjarke Ingels’ Storm Protection System

Posted On Wed, July 6, 2016 By

Posted On Wed, July 6, 2016 By In Policy, Technology, Urban Design

“Not only is New York City going to build the cheapest, ugliest version of the big dumb wall, there’s a very good possibility that it won’t even be big enough.”

According to a recent Rolling Stone article titled “Can New York Be Saved in the Era of Global Warming?” the level of storm protection put in place to protect the city from future superstorms may fall short of the elegant solution that was originally promised. According to the story, the city funded a proposal–Danish firm Bjarke Ingels Group (BIG)’s winning submission in the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Rebuild by Design contest–that involved a 10-mile barrier system that would protect Lower Manhattan from the ruinous effects of storm surges and sea-level rise. Called the Big U, the $540 million infrastructure project would be designed to contain parks and public spaces. But because of cost issues, the project may not materialize as planned.

The barrier “sponge” that would help insulate the city against future Sandy-like storms is currently being created by BIG. It was promised that the 16-foot steel and concrete berms would be “cleverly disguised as skate parks, public pools, urban farms, bird sanctuaries, and marshland trails.”

big u 4
BIG’s proposed approach weaves its way around Manhattan, responding to community needs with parks, paths and play spaces.

According to the story, architects and urban planners familiar with the project say that due to its cost and complexity, the finished product is “just going to be a big dumb wall.” And as is often the case when barrier walls are built, there is resistance to living next to them. There is concern that the the structure will affect property values, with neighbors wanting to be on the “right” side of it; the story cites the ongoing battle in Hoboken involving the OMA-designed sea wall that has been facing intense community opposition.

big u 5
The masterplan includes physically autonomous flood-protection zones that can be individually isolated.

The worse issue of all, though, may be the system’s shortcomings when it comes to actually protecting our communities from possible storm damage. The barrier is clearly be intended to protect the Wall Street area, but what about waterfront communities like Red Hook, Brooklyn, who would suffer even more severe consequences?

The story cites the fact that in the Netherlands, for example, barriers are required to go much further in their storm protection capabilities, and some predict that global warming will make Sandy-like storms a more likely occurrence. Protecting against a bigger “500-year storm,” though, would be more expensive, which, at the moment, may be the deciding factor.

[Rolling Stone via Gizmodo]

RELATED:

All images courtesy of Rebuild by Design / Bjarke Ingels Group

Tags : , , , ,

  • jules

    Shouldn’t they be getting on with this shit. Just build a levy out at sea as they do in European countries… Oh wait, then the MTA wont be able to use the alleged exuse for doing nothing due to … ‘whatever’? Sandy? Endless excuses. The Big Apple is becomming rotten to the core. Kickbacks are all there is.

MOST RECENT ARTICLES

  • Brooklyn cheesemongers to open their underground 1850s brewery tunnels for one night

    Brooklyn cheesemongers to open their underground 1850s brewery tunnels for one night

    Thirty feet below street level, Benton Brown and Susan Boyle of Crown Finish Caves age their deliciously moldy wares in ...
  • Explore historic LGBT sites in NYC with this interactive map

    Explore historic LGBT sites in NYC with this interactive map

    To broaden people’s knowledge of the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community’s history in New York City, the NYC LGBT ...
  • ‘Cash Cab’ will return later this year; Paul Manafort’s shady NYC real estate dealings

    ‘Cash Cab’ will return later this year; Paul Manafort’s shady NYC real estate dealings

    New York-based designer (and 13-year U.S. citizen) Karim Rashid said he had a “crazy journey” getting by US Border Control at JFK. ...
  • ‘Fearless Girl’ statue will remain on Wall Street for another year, but officials say that’s not enough

    ‘Fearless Girl’ statue will remain on Wall Street for another year, but officials say that’s not enough

    Image via Metro / Getty The drumbeat for making the statue of Fearless Girl a permanent fixture in Lower Manhattan ...
  • Investor flips Trump’s childhood home for double what he paid, likely selling to Chinese buyer

    Investor flips Trump’s childhood home for double what he paid, likely selling to Chinese buyer

    When Manhattan real estate mogul Michael Davis bought Donald Trump’s childhood home sight-unseen for just under $1.4 million in December, he ...
  • ‘Narnia’ apartment in Park Slope has a hidden door and built-in swing

    ‘Narnia’ apartment in Park Slope has a hidden door and built-in swing

    The listing calls this apartment a “gateway to a modern version of Narnia”–and it’s hard not to agree. A designer ...
  • 15 indoor air-purifying plants for your apartment or home

    15 indoor air-purifying plants for your apartment or home

    Our ongoing series Apartment Living 101 is aimed at helping New Yorkers navigate the challenges of creating a happy home in the big ...
  • Justin Timberlake and Jessica Biel are bringing sexy back to Tribeca with new penthouse buy

    Justin Timberlake and Jessica Biel are bringing sexy back to Tribeca with new penthouse buy

    Although Justin Timberlake was spotted scoping out an $18.5 million Greenwich Village penthouse last month, he chose Tribeca to call home ...
  • First look at the interiors of Waterline Square’s trio of towers

    First look at the interiors of Waterline Square’s trio of towers

    As 6sqft reported in November, a trio of glassy residential towers is rising on the five-acre waterfront site between West 59th and ...
  • Frank Lloyd Wright Fallingwater lookalike asks $3.5M in Greenwich, CT

    Frank Lloyd Wright Fallingwater lookalike asks $3.5M in Greenwich, CT

    Designed by local architect Dimitri Bulazel, this 4,675-square-foot four-bedroom home at 51 Pecksland Road in Greenwich, CT was clearly inspired by Frank ...
  • Elegant co-op in an UES mansion still has its original leaded casement windows

    Elegant co-op in an UES mansion still has its original leaded casement windows

    This two-bedroom co-op occupies the parlor and garden floors of 4 East 82nd Street, a stately Carnegie Hill mansion. Despite ...
  • Kickstarter campaign raising $10,000 for a 15-foot inflatable ‘Trumpy’ rat

    Kickstarter campaign raising $10,000 for a 15-foot inflatable ‘Trumpy’ rat

    As a symbol of resistance to the Trump administration, Chelsea-based contemporary art gallery BravinLee created a Kickstarter to raise $10,000 ...

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTERS

Thank you, your sign-up request was successful!
This email address is already subscribed, thank you!
Please provide a valid email address.
Please complete the CAPTCHA.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later.