Country-chic West Village ‘house within a house’ asks $3.25M
Listing photos by Brynne Levy Photography for Compass
In the heart of the West Village at 53 Horatio Street, this three-bedroom home has just listed for $3.25 million. The 1834 Federal rowhouse was divided into six co-ops, but the units still retain their 19th-century charm. This residence spans an impressive four floors, hence why the listing describes it as a “house within a house.” In addition to its spacious, vertical layout, the apartment is the perfect mix of country decor and contemporary amenities.
![]()
![]()
The home has four wood-burning fireplaces throughout, including one on the parlor floor which is nice and bright thanks to an oversized, south-facing window. A custom, built-in banquette works as a lovely breakfast nook, and there a separate sitting area, as well. This floor also has a powder room.
![]()
![]()
Down on the garden level is a kitchen that was renovated in 2016. It boasts top-of-the-line appliances, glass-fronted cabinets, and enough space for a large dining table. Off the kitchen is a full bath. On the other side of the floor is a flexible bedroom/den with another wood-burning fireplace, this one with an original brick surround. There’s custom overhead storage and a Murphy bed (see the white wall next to the fireplace.)
![]()
![]()
Up on the second level is a large bedroom with the third fireplace, an exposed brick wall, and elegant shutters on the south-facing windows. There’s an en-suite bathroom and deep closet.
![]()
![]()
The top floor currently functions as the master suite and has the same configuration as the bedroom below.
![]()
53 Horatio Street is about as charming as it gets in the Village. The brick rowhouse has a part-time superintendent, video security, and common storage space in the lobby. Unfortunately, pets and pied-a-terres are not permitted.
[Listing: 53 Horatio Street, #1 by Nick Gavin and Josh Doyle of Compass]
[At CityRealty]
Listing photos by Brynne Levy Photography for Compass