After a battle to be the ‘world’s largest,’ two NYC menorahs continue to spread light

Posted On Fri, November 30, 2018 By

Posted On Fri, November 30, 2018 By In Events, History, holidays

Manhattan’s Menorah being lit by Danny Danon, Israel’s Ambassador to the UN, in 2016. Via Chabad Lubavitch/Flickr.

In the mid-1970s, former Chabad Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson encouraged his emissaries to build public menorahs in major cities and organize nightly lightings to increase public awareness about Hanukkah and inspire fellow Jews to light menorahs in their homes. Decades later, Chabad rabbis continue the effort in cities worldwide, but in New York the practice hasn’t always been peaceful. The tradition ended up creating a friendly competition between rival menorahs in Brooklyn and Manhattan, who both claimed to be “The World’s Largest.”

Brooklyn’s Menorah being lit by Mayor Bill de Blasio in 2016. Via Chabad Lubavitch/Flickr.

In 1973, Rabbi Shmuel Butman erected a menorah in Manhattan, where it still stands every year, on Fifth Avenue at the southeastern corner of Central Park. About a decade later, in 1984, Rabbi Shimon Hecht built his at Grand Army Plaza in Park Slope.

Both menorahs are actually the same height, 32 feet, the maximum allowed by Jewish law. But the central candle in Hecht’s menorah — called the shamash — is six inches taller than Butman’s. In 2006 The Guiness Book of World Records gave Manhattan a slight edge by certifying the Fifth Avenue menorah as the “World’s Largest Menorah,” but the claim to fame would not be settled until 2016 when a Chabad-Lubavitch rabbinical court weighed in on the matter.

As The New York Jewish Week reported, the court decided that Hecht could not claim Brooklyn had the largest menorah — even though, technically, it is — because the Manhattan menorah used the moniker first, and so the court ruled that they owned the title.

“Every Hanukkah operation is meant for publicizing the miracle in a way that sanctifies God’s name and the name of Chabad, and not, God forbid, the opposite,” the judges wrote in the December 1, 2016 decision. “When another organization in the same city uses the same descriptor without permission from the plaintiff, it could cause the opposite of respect to Lubavitch.”

Rabbi Hecht still owns and uses the website, but after this ruling he conceded to a subtle rebranding and added — in very small font — “Brooklyn” to their logo, so that it reads “Brooklyn’s Largest Menorah.”

Each year, the lighting ceremonies draw thousands of people. In the wake of the attack on the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh and in the face of growing anti semitism, it is expected that this year will draw even more attendants than usual to the festival of lights. “When faced with darkness and hatred, the light of the menorah serves as a symbol of strength and inspiration, democracy and freedom for all people, delivering a timely and poignant message to each person on an individual basis,” Rabbi Butman said in a recent statement.

Starting on Sunday, the schedule of menorah lightings in Manhattan is:

December 2 at 5:30 p.m.
December 3 at 5:30 p.m.
December 4 at 5:30 p.m.
December 5 at 5:30 p.m.
December 6 at 5:30 p.m.
December 7 at 3:30 p.m.
December 8 at 8:30 p.m.
December 9 at 5:30 p.m.

And in Brooklyn:

December 2 A live, kickoff concert begins at 4:30 pm
December 3 at 6:00 pm
December 4 at 6:00 pm
December 5 at 6:00 pm
December 6 at 6:00 pm
December 7 at 3:30 pm
December 8 at 7:00 pm
December 9 at 5:30pm


Tags : ,



Thank you, your sign-up request was successful!
This email address is already subscribed, thank you!
Please provide a valid email address.
Please complete the CAPTCHA.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later.