Trump’s Flubs: The Donald’s Failed Attempts to Erect the World’s Tallest Building in NYC

Posted On Tue, April 26, 2016 By

Posted On Tue, April 26, 2016 By In Architecture, Celebrities, Features

Presidential candidate Donald Trump‘s aggressive tone and occasional outlandish statements have dominated the conversation in the Republican primaries, and today is sure to be no different. Though his supporters feel that he’s a shoo-in, his real estate track record hasn’t always resulted in success. Take for example his fraught attempt to own the Empire State Building, which ended in lawsuits and public shaming, or his $80 million loss on the Plaza Hotel, which resulted from his near bankruptcy in the ’90s.

In addition to these public debacles, the developer-turned-showman-turned-politician has envisioned at least three of the world’s tallest buildings in New York over the years, which makes sense for a man who glories in superlatives and for whom every project is a flamboyant gesture. In honor of the Donald’s never-ending presence, 6sqft decided to take a look at these never-realized, sky-high proposals, which include the New York Stock Exchange Tower, Television City Tower, and 10 Columbus Circle.

New York Stock Exchange Tower  
Kohn Pedersen Fox
140 stories | 1,792 feet
Commercial office
Never built | 1996

Kohn Pedersen Fox, Donald Trump, New York Stock Exchange TowerRendering of the New York Stock Exchange Tower by Richard Baehr

In 1996, Trump proposed building the world’s tallest building for the New York Stock Exchange on pilings at the foot of Wall Street. Envisioned to rise 140 floors and 1,792 feet high, the Kohn Pedersen Fox-designed tower would eclipse the then tallest Sears Tower (now Willis Tower) by more than 30 stories and wold take nearly four years to build. To be known as New York Stock Exchange Tower, the tampering and chamfered glass tower (not unlike One World Trade) was to encapsulate 3.5 million square feet of office space and estimated to house 100,000 office workers.

While City Hall and then NYSE Chief Executive Richard Grasso greeted the plan with “huge enthusiasm,” the offshore site was not owned by Trump and would have had to clear countless governmental hurdles. The East River site had also been the location of numerous failed proposals before including Manhattan Landing, a downtown Guggenheim location, and more recently, Seaport City. The exchange later mulled moving a 51-story tower designed by Skidmore Owings & Merrill directly across from their current location at the corner of Broad and Wall Streets. Ultimately, the attacks of 9/11 and the resulting economic downturn shelved relocation plans.

 

Television City Tower 
Murphy/Jahn Architects
150 stories | 1,670 feet
Mixed-use
Never built | 1985/1988

Trump City, Donald Trump, Television City Tower
Rendering of Trump City

In 1974, Donald Trump, then a fledgling developer with a full head of his own hair, first published plans to build a 12,450- unit master plan on the abandoned West Side rail yards of the Penn Central Railroad. After acquiring the sprawling “once in a lifetime,” 100-acre site a decade later, Trump commissioned the Chicago firm of Murphy/Jahn Architects to lead the design for Trump City. A 1985 press release trumpeted the vision as “the master builder’s grandest plan yet.”

At the development’s center, on axis to West 66th Street, would be the world’s tallest building, standing 150 stories and 1,670 foot high. The tower proposal, which was tri-axial in plan a la engineering marvel Burj Khalifa, would accommodate offices on its lower floors and more than 100 floors of apartments above. Six 72-story towers and a 65-story office tower would accompany the supertall, and altogether the scheme would yield 8,000 apartments, 3.6 million square feet of television and motion picture studios, 1.7 million square feet of retail, 8,500 parking spaces, and 40 acres of open space. The entire development would be raised on a platform on level with the adjacent elevated West Side Highway.

Unsurprisingly, the monumental plan drew plenty of criticism. Esteemed architect Michael Sorkin remarked, “Looking at the boneheaded proposal, one wonders whether the architect even visited the site,” and regarding Trump he asks, “Was ever a man more preoccupied with getting it up in public?” Paul Goldberger, then architecture critic at the Times, questioned the sensibility of building a residences that high, saying, “Living 120 or 130 or 140 stories up in the air is fine stuff for fairy tales, but it has little appeal in real life.” After a series of alternative proposals, planners settled with the mediocre and forgettable design realized today. Now known as Trump Place, the site holds a prosaic ensemble of 16 mid-rise towers meant to be within context to the Upper West Side.

 

10 Columbus Circle / Coliseum Site 

Eli Attia
137 stories | 1,600 feet
Never built | 1985

Murphy/Jahn Architects
135 stories | 1,275 feet
Never built | 1985

Robert A.M. Stern
750 feet
Never built | 1996

When the Javits Center was completed in 1986, it sealed the fate of the Coliseum, a convention center that stood at Columbus Circle from 1956 to 2000. In the years leading up to its eventual demolition, developers and architects had grand visions for what could become of the prime site. In 1984, the city, state, and Municipal Assistance Corporation agreed to offer the 150,000-square-foot parcel for lease, claiming it could hold “the tallest building in the world.” The following year, the MTA (who was responsible for the site) placed it on the market, asking prospective bidders to submit design proposals. The only requirements were that the plans have retail space along Columbus Circle with a base that conformed to the curves of the Circle.

10 Columbus Circle, Eli Attia, Donald Trump, New York Coliseum
Design by Eli Attia. Rendering by Michael McCann

Thirteen developers submitted proposals, including yours truly Donald Trump, who was working in partnership with Peter Kalikow (former Chairman of the MTA, former Commissioner of the Port Authority, and past owner of the New York Post). They worked with architect Eli Attia, who designed a 137-story decagonal tower with offices, a hotel, residential space, and a top-floor observation deck. As explained in “New York 2000, “Given the limit on allowable square footage, Attia’s proposal achieved its extraordinary height by means of a thirty-story hollow core intended as an atrium. Additionally, to achieve large open floors, the design had no interior columns, relying on an exterior steel frame.”

Murphy/Jahn Architects, 10 Columbus Circle, New York Coliseum, Donald Trump
Design by Murphy/Jahn

Not to be outdone, Trump and Kalikow also submitted a second design from Murphy/Jahn, this one a 135-story, octagonal, terraced building that spiraled upward. Again, Michael Sorkin spoke out against the scheme, saying in the Village Voice, “I’m in favor of the world’s tallest building. It just doesn’t belong in Columbus Circle.” Goldberger agreed, calling the proposals “no more than a pretentious parade of overblown skyscrapers, a packaged set of every design cliche of the last decade.” He specifically called out Attia’s design for Trump, opining that it looked “like storybook pictures of the Tower of Babel, and it could not be less appropriate for Columbus Circe.” The Murphy/Jahn design, he felt was “not much better in terms of its relationship to the surrounding city, but at least its central void promised to preserve an open vista westward from Central Park South.”

Robert A.M. Stern, 10 Columbus Circle, Donald Trump, New York Coliseum
Design by Robert A.M. Stern. Renderings by Ernest Burden III

Ultimately, another proposal was chosen, and for the next decade, the city, developers, and politicians went round and round with who would purchase the site and what would be built there. By 1995, the MTA announced that it would start from scratch and issued a new request for proposals. This time, the height was capped at 59 stories, and nine teams submitted bids. Trump once again threw his hat in the ring, partnering with Colony Capital and enlisting Robert A.M. Stern and Costas Kondylis. They proposed a 750-foot tower angled towards the park with bay windows and a modulated top that resembled the early skyscrapers of Manhattan. It was rumored that Trump offered up to $300 million for the site, namely to protect the views of his nearby Trump International Hotel & Tower. But in yet another snag, in 1998 the city and state decided to ask for re-submissions. Trump’s interest had already begun to fade, and when Time Warner joined forces with the Related Companies, his single-slab design became less popular, as did his outspoken ego. Later that year, Related paid $345 million for the site, eventually giving birth to the Time Warner Center.

+++ 

Additional reporting by Dana Schulz 

RELATED:

Tags : , , , , , , ,

  • Ernest Burden

    Please credit the artists who’s work you post. It is a requirement of the ‘fair use’ clause in US copyright, and good form for an architectural news site.

    The KPF design was rendered by Richard Baehr
    The second scheme is a model photo
    The Eli Attia design was rendered by Michael McCann
    The Murphy/Jahn design was rendered by … I can’t recall the name but the work is familiar
    The Robert A.M. Stern design was rendered by me, Ernest Burden

  • patec1

    At least his architects have taste and an understanding of the spirit of the city. Any of them beat the 432 Park Avenue atrocity. These work nicely into the skyline although too tall.

  • Marbella Fitz-Williams

    Setting politics aside (which I see it may be hard to do after reading your slights), how about setting time aside regarding the positive outcomes Mr. Trump has done for the City? I’m sure you can find something nice to say…maybe.

  • Johnny Appleseed

    What was the name of the NYC project in the early ’70s that trump built on a toxic landfill site?

MOST RECENT ARTICLES

  • Park Slope co-op with custom bookshelves reaching 18 feet asks $1.65M

    Park Slope co-op with custom bookshelves reaching 18 feet asks $1.65M

    A renovation for this Park Slope co-op left it in lovely condition. The lofty floorplan–which boasts 18-foot ceilings–was taken full ...
  • Weekly highlights: Top picks from the 6sqft staff

    Weekly highlights: Top picks from the 6sqft staff

    Swale floating park returns this spring with a new look Kushner Cos. vision for 666 Fifth Avenue has Zaha Hadid ...
  • Stackable furniture line from Debra Folz Design makes storage stylish

    Stackable furniture line from Debra Folz Design makes storage stylish

    There are all types of stackable furniture out there, and while many of them function perfectly well, they’re not always ...
  • This $4M Riverdale mansion, known as the Esmeralda, was built in 1899 and still impresses today

    This $4M Riverdale mansion, known as the Esmeralda, was built in 1899 and still impresses today

    The historic mansions of Riverdale never fail to impress, and this gem is no exception. Built in 1899 and known ...
  • Renzo Piano’s 565 Broome Street on the rise; the world of Hamilton at Green-Wood Cemetery

    Renzo Piano’s 565 Broome Street on the rise; the world of Hamilton at Green-Wood Cemetery

    After launching sales in September, Renzo Piano’s two-towered 565 Broome Street is finally on the rise. [CityRealty] The quest to ...
  • FREE RENT: This week’s roundup of NYC’s rental concessions

    FREE RENT: This week’s roundup of NYC’s rental concessions

    Upper West Side Beaux Arts Beauty ‘The Willard’ Offering Two Months Free, 1-Bedrooms From $2,996/Month [link] Live at LIC’s Hayden: ...
  • 432 Park would have generated $30M for affordable housing with de Blasio’s mansion tax

    432 Park would have generated $30M for affordable housing with de Blasio’s mansion tax

    Outside of 432 Park Avenue, Mayor de Blasio held a press conference on Thursday to discuss his mansion tax. The ...
  • City reveals garment district rezoning plans, citing incentives to move makers to Sunset Park

    City reveals garment district rezoning plans, citing incentives to move makers to Sunset Park

    At a Manhattan community board meeting Wednesday evening, city officials told garment industry representatives of plans to remove Midtown‘s manufacturing ...
  • The Urban Lens: Behind the counter and into the caves at Murray’s Cheese

    The Urban Lens: Behind the counter and into the caves at Murray’s Cheese

    6sqft’s ongoing series The Urban Lens invites photographers to share work exploring a theme or a place within New York City. ...
  • New renderings revealed for NYCHA’s raised earth Red Hook Houses by KPF

    New renderings revealed for NYCHA’s raised earth Red Hook Houses by KPF

    When Superstorm Sandy hit the community of Red Hook, thousands of residents were left without power and basic necessities for ...
  • Judge once again stops work at Pier 55 over environmental concerns

    Judge once again stops work at Pier 55 over environmental concerns

    If you thought the roller coaster that is Pier 55 was over since construction began in November, you may not want ...
  • Amtrak will provide additional weekend service between Boston and New York

    Amtrak will provide additional weekend service between Boston and New York

    Amtrak will soon offer more weekend service options between Boston and New York, the railroad company announced Thursday. Those who ...

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTERS

Thank you, your sign-up request was successful!
This email address is already subscribed, thank you!
Please provide a valid email address.
Please complete the CAPTCHA.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later.