New Studies Show Historic Preservation Doesn’t Cause Gentrification Woes

Posted On Mon, May 16, 2016 By

Posted On Mon, May 16, 2016 By In gentrification, Policy

The city’s preservation groups have reported that the results of a series of studies, prompted by the 50th anniversary of the city’s Landmarks Law, have put some numbers behind the claim that landmarking doesn’t harm, and may actually improve, the economic balance of neighborhood development and growth. According to Simeon Bankoff, executive director of the Historic Districts Council, “This is the first time which preservationists–who tend to be from the humanities and subsequently math-averse–have put real data behind anecdotes.” The combined reports represent the most comprehensive study to date of the impacts of historic preservation in New York City.

Williamsburg-gentrification

6sqft recently highlighted the results of a related study by the Furman Center comparing the city’s gentrifying neighborhoods. In addition to that comparison, the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation points to the fact that the study looks at the percentage by which average rents have increased from 1990 to 2014 in sections of the city (a reliable measure of “gentrification”). Williamsburg/Greenpoint, which showed the highest rent increase from 1990 to 2014–78.7 percent–is also an area of the city that happens to have very little landmarking (just 2.8 percent according to the Furman Center). The area also has a large amount of new construction, exactly what detractors of landmarking say is needed to bring soaring prices down.

Another just-released study, conducted by the non-profit Historic Districts Council titled “The Intersection of Affordable Housing and Historic Districts” analyzed data for New York City’s historic districts using U.S. Census Bureau affordability and income indicators including rental prices, income, and rental burden (referring to tenants who are paying 30 percent or more of their pre-tax income on gross rent), as well as building-level affordability indicators. The study found that “between the years 1970 and 2010, historic district designation had relatively little bearing on rental prices and the number of rent-burdened households, although historic district designation did correlate with an increase in income in some designated historic districts…In fact, the percentage point increase in rental housing burden in all NYC census tracts was more than twice that (18.1 percentage points) of census tracts overlapping with historic districts (8.8 percentage points).” It also found that historic district designation didn’t prevent government-subsidized housing from developing in specific neighborhoods, nor did it prevent subsidized units from remaining affordable.

A study by the non-profit Landmarks Conservancy found that subsidized units in many historic districts remain affordable whether the units were developed before or after historic district designation. Overall in New York City, affordability subsidies are maintained as of 2010 in historic districts at a rate of 74.6 percent, compared to 73.4 perfect in non-designated areas.

Another analysis, also by the NYU Furman Center, titled “50 Years of Historic Landmarking in New York City” shows the extent of preservation in New York City and compares the land use, housing stock, demographic characteristics, and commercial property in historic districts with those in areas not regulated by the Landmarks Preservation Commission (LPC). Some key facts:

  • Within historic districts, six out of every 1,000 lots saw a new building constructed between 2004 and 2014, compared to 39 out of every 1,000 lots outside of historic districts.
  • Lots in historic districts saw the same levels of officially recorded alteration activity between 2004 and 2014 as non-LPC-designated lots in the same community district.
  • Historic districts had a higher market-rate share of multifamily rental units than non-LPC-regulated areas.

According to Bankoff, “We would be the first to say that correlation is not causation, and one should view these statistics in their appropriate context. But one thing these statistics do clearly show is that there is no obvious connection between landmark designated areas of New York City and increasing unaffordability, at least as compared to non-landmarked areas. And certainly they show that large amounts of new housing construction, even when that housing construction includes some affordable units, does not necessarily tend to make an area more affordable.”

The reports underscore the preservation groups’ long-held opinion that, while the long-term social values of preservation are are valid, there are also compelling near-term reasons to preserve and celebrate the city’s built heritage.

RELATED:

Images © CityRealty

Tags : , ,

MOST RECENT ARTICLES

  • Elegant co-op in an UES mansion still has its original leaded casement windows

    Elegant co-op in an UES mansion still has its original leaded casement windows

    This two-bedroom co-op occupies the parlor and garden floors of 4 East 82nd Street, a stately Carnegie Hill mansion. Despite ...
  • Kickstarter campaign raising $10,000 for a 15-foot inflatable ‘Trumpy’ rat

    Kickstarter campaign raising $10,000 for a 15-foot inflatable ‘Trumpy’ rat

    As a symbol of resistance to the Trump administration, Chelsea-based contemporary art gallery BravinLee created a Kickstarter to raise $10,000 ...
  • Petition started to force Melania Trump out of NYC

    Petition started to force Melania Trump out of NYC

    Fed up with the price of protecting the first lady in her ritzy Manhattan high-rise, taxpayers are urging members of the ...
  • World Trade Center Performing Arts Center may be delayed again

    World Trade Center Performing Arts Center may be delayed again

    It’s been almost 13 years since Frank Gehry initially designed the Performing Arts Center at the World Trade Center (PACWTC). ...
  • The cost of exporting trash in NYC is expected to soar

    The cost of exporting trash in NYC is expected to soar

    As the population of New York City continues to rise, so does the amount of garbage lining its sidewalks. But ...
  • ‘Fearless Girl’ statue will remain through 2018; Alligators delay first Citywide Ferry boat’s journey

    ‘Fearless Girl’ statue will remain through 2018; Alligators delay first Citywide Ferry boat’s journey

    The owner of the illegal Trump Tower Airbnb listing was fined $1,000. [NYT] And the investor who bought Donald Trump’s childhood ...
  • ODA’s slender-waisted ‘Orbit Tower’ wins the Metals in Construction 2017 Design Challenge

    ODA’s slender-waisted ‘Orbit Tower’ wins the Metals in Construction 2017 Design Challenge

    Metals in Construction magazine has just announced the winner and finalists in the magazine’s 2017 Design Challenge, “Meeting the Architecture ...
  • Gem of a two-bedroom in the East Village is both cute and cozy

    Gem of a two-bedroom in the East Village is both cute and cozy

    We’re guessing it’s probably just coincidence, that there are so many charming, pre-war co-ops on this tranquil and lovely East Village street, ...
  • Construction update: Extell’s Central Park Tower gets its fluted glass curtain wall

    Construction update: Extell’s Central Park Tower gets its fluted glass curtain wall

    West 58th Street elevation of Nordstom’s podium; CityRealty When it reaches its projected 1,550-foot height, Extell Development’s Central Park Tower ...
  • Ai Weiwei will bring over 100 fence art installations to NYC this fall

    Ai Weiwei will bring over 100 fence art installations to NYC this fall

    Internationally renowned Chinese contemporary artist and activist Ai Weiwei was banned from leaving his home country for more than four ...
  • Eight chances to live in a new East Williamsburg building, from $985/month

    Eight chances to live in a new East Williamsburg building, from $985/month

    A state-of-the-art fitness center, yoga room, roof deck with cabanas, designer interiors, and a prime East Williamsburg location just a ...
  • Distinctive 1969 modern Westchester County home designed by Frank Lloyd Wright acolyte asks $1.1M

    Distinctive 1969 modern Westchester County home designed by Frank Lloyd Wright acolyte asks $1.1M

    Nestled in a wooded enclave in the tranquil town of Briarcliff Manor in Westchester County, NY, this striking midcentury modern house was built ...

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTERS

Thank you, your sign-up request was successful!
This email address is already subscribed, thank you!
Please provide a valid email address.
Please complete the CAPTCHA.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later.