Local Pols Say Port Authority’s $10B Bus Terminal Plan Is a Hot Mess

Posted On Fri, July 22, 2016 By

Posted On Fri, July 22, 2016 By In Major Developments, Midtown West

A request to put the brakes on a $10 billion plan for a new West Side bus terminal and rethink the process with more input from local officials and the public was rebuffed by the Port Authority chairman, reports Crain’s. Rep. Jerrold Nadler and Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer were joined by Deputy Mayor Anthony Shorris, state Sen. Brad Hoylman, Assembly members Richard Gottfried and Linda Rosenthal and Councilman Corey Johnson in backing the effort to slow the Port Authority’s call to move ahead with a design competition to get ideas for the West Side plan.

The controversy emerged after a board meeting on Thursday. “We’re not going to defer the design and deliverability study,” was the reply from John Degnan, the New Jersey-appointed chairman, amid concerns that the new terminal will necessitate the seizure of private property using eminent domain, threaten area homes, small businesses and other organizations and belch more carbon from a larger fleet of buses into the air in an area that already “runs afoul of federal air-quality standards.”

According to Nadler, “The design competition assumes a lot of the answers,” referring to the quick dismissal of earlier ideas–like moving a portion of the bus terminal to New Jersey–and studies on ways the new terminal could be coordinated with other major transit projects. Degnan replied that the officials would have an opportunity to weigh in on the bus terminal project going forward: “[The design competition’s] result will provide the basis upon which the dialogue that was requested can take place…I don’t see a reason to defer a process that is simply an early step,” and that the opposition from officials was something that “every project at some point runs into.”

Back in March, the Port Authority’s then-vice-chairman Scott Rechler had urged the agency to investigate less costly options–like new bus routes and infrastructure that would allow transfers between bus and train service west of the Hudson. Degnan threatened to pull his support for a $4 billion central terminal project at LaGuardia Airport if Rechler didn’t support his request that the bus terminal be located on Manhattan’s West Side; Rechler grudgingly agreed to Degnan’s request.

In a letter released Wednesday, the New York officials said the decision to locate the terminal in Manhattan was made before a capacity study was able to properly evaluate the demands the terminal would make on future commuting patterns. Degnan countered by insisting that the design competition had, in fact, urged submissions to minimize or even eliminate the use of eminent domain, and that the new terminal would actually improve local air quality because buses would have room to park rather than idling on the street during rush hour as they currently do.

According to DNA info, the local pols want to call a halt. “The Port Authority has put the bus before the horse,” Brewer said Thursday. “They’ve mounted the design competition for a new bus terminal footprint in a process that has been publicly opaque, that virtually no one in this community has been allowed input on.” Gottfried added that “Port Authority literally does not know what they’re doing.” “The residents of Hell’s Kitchen should not be thrown under this bus terminal,” because of a deal that favors New Jersey residents, state Sen. Brad Hoylman added.

[Via Crain’s; DNA Info]

RELATED:

Tags : , , , , ,

Neighborhoods : Midtown West

  • Andrew Doolittle

    “Thrown under the bus terminal.” That’s a good one. Manhattan needs to take a look at Bus only routes and keep moving forward on the extraordinary transit improvement s already made and well underway and soon to be underway. This is the most valuable piece of Real Estate in the World right now so the project is moving forward irregardless. Having said that building tunnels that connect Hudson Yards to the Terminal to Times Square to Grand Central…walking only…if done right…would keep the City and it’s environs moving in the right direction. Amazing it’s under consideration actually.

MOST RECENT ARTICLES

  • Philip Johnson’s Rockefeller Guest House, a ‘secret’ modernist gem on Manhattan’s east side

    Philip Johnson’s Rockefeller Guest House, a ‘secret’ modernist gem on Manhattan’s east side

    Just down the street from the now-closed modernist treasure trove and icon that was the Four Seasons in Manhattan’s east ...
  • Bioswales face backlash from city residents for being eyesores

    Bioswales face backlash from city residents for being eyesores

    While you may have never heard of the term “bioswale,” you have probably seen these curbside gardens throughout the city. ...
  • David Bowie’s former Central Park South condo lists for $6.5M with his personal piano included

    David Bowie’s former Central Park South condo lists for $6.5M with his personal piano included

    Sure, a piano is always a nice touch, especially in a classic Central Park South condo like this. But when ...
  • How elevators are adapting to supertall towers; Get Shake Shack delivered

    How elevators are adapting to supertall towers; Get Shake Shack delivered

    17th century Barberini tapestries now on view at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine. [Untapped] Baseball commentator and former ...
  • Former Citicorp Center might lose Sasaki fountain as part of plaza redesign

    Former Citicorp Center might lose Sasaki fountain as part of plaza redesign

    Earlier this month, 6sqft revealed renderings of 601 Lexington Avenue‘s (the Midtown East skyscraper formerly known as the Citicorp Center) new ...
  • Art Nerd New York’s top event picks for the week – 3/23-3/29

    Art Nerd New York’s top event picks for the week – 3/23-3/29

    In a city where hundreds of interesting events occur each week, it can be hard to pick and choose your ...
  • Iconic ballet dancer Mikhail Baryshnikov buys Harlem condo for $1.4 million

    Iconic ballet dancer Mikhail Baryshnikov buys Harlem condo for $1.4 million

    Mikhail Baryshnikov, who fled the Soviet Union in 1974 and landed in Canada is today considered one of the greatest ballet dancers ...
  • Starting Monday, three Brooklyn R train stations will shut down for six months

    Starting Monday, three Brooklyn R train stations will shut down for six months

    Last January, Governor Cuomo announced a massive undertaking to “modernize and fundamentally transform” the MTA and the subway by adding ...
  • Greta Garbo’s exclusive East Side co-op hits the market for the first time in 64 years, asking $6M

    Greta Garbo’s exclusive East Side co-op hits the market for the first time in 64 years, asking $6M

    For the first time in decades, an apartment in The Campanile, an exclusive co-op building in the Beekman/Sutton Place neighborhood, ...
  • The least affordable U.S. city for public transit isn’t NYC (and more fun facts about the cost of commuting)

    The least affordable U.S. city for public transit isn’t NYC (and more fun facts about the cost of commuting)

    In light of NYC’s recent subway fare hike that bumped the price of a monthly pass to $121, the data jocks ...
  • For $675K this tiny West Village studio is big on rustic loft style

    For $675K this tiny West Village studio is big on rustic loft style

    This completely renovated loft-style studio co-op at 9 Barrow Street may be tiny with little more than 300 square feet of ...
  • Dreamy furnished studio with lots of greenery asks $3,200/month in the East Village

    Dreamy furnished studio with lots of greenery asks $3,200/month in the East Village

    This furnished rental at 527 East 12th Street in the East Village is downright dreamy. The exposed brick has been painted white ...

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTERS

Thank you, your sign-up request was successful!
This email address is already subscribed, thank you!
Please provide a valid email address.
Please complete the CAPTCHA.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later.