18th-century Sag Harbor home is a mix of history and whimsy for $3M
Photo credit: Mike Heller
This picture-perfect Sag Harbor home was originally built in 1791, and a modern restoration in 2013 brought it “back to its former glory,” according to the listing. After spending some time as a $1,950/night vacation rental, the home is now on the market for $2,950,000. Inside, the three-bedroom house mixes historic bones with whimsical details, a combo that is echoed outside, where a pergola-covered dining area and secret garden surround the pool.
![]()
![]()
The home is 1,500 square feet and has three bedrooms and two bathrooms. The front parlor has the first of three fireplaces, and the dining room has a cool built-in office nook and a custom whaling mural commissioned by the owner.
![]()
The kitchen mixes contemporary Wolf appliances with rustic cabinetry and a brick hearth.
![]()
The master bedroom with en-suite bathroom is also on the first floor. Moody gray walls complement the fireplace, and a door opens to the backyard.
![]()
![]()
There are two more bedrooms and a full bath on the second floor. The third floor holds a playroom/office.
![]()
![]()
![]()
Outside, the heated Gunite plunge pool is surrounded by beautiful landscaping and a large patio. There are several areas for dining and lounging, one of which is under an ivy-covered pergola.
![]()
The home is just one block from all the shops and restaurants along Main Street.
[Listing: 47 Madison Street by David Cox of Compass]
RELATED:
- Famous artist couple lists their 1797 Sag Harbor house for $3.5M
- ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ star Ellen Pompeo sells Sag Harbor farmhouse for $3M
- For $3.5M, this 1829 Amagansett farmhouse is the picture of East End tranquility, pool included
Photo credit: Mike Heller