For $12M, this six-floor Carnegie Hill townhouse has a penthouse gym and a private carriage house
Get More Info

For $12M, this six-floor Carnegie Hill townhouse has a penthouse gym and a private carriage house

November 17, 2026

All photos courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens

The Carnegie Hill townhouse at 168 East 91st Street is the kind of home you see in the movies, in that scene where the kid visits their rich friend and realizes the level of luxury that’s hiding in plain sight in the city. Asking $11,950,000, the 25-foot-wide home on the Upper East Side has six floors and an elevator to reach them. There are several terraces, a penthouse gym, and a separate carriage house in the back.

Built in 1889, the historic townhouse has been updated from stem to stern with no expense spared, of course. New structural steel, plumbing, electrical, and mechanical systems frame interiors that offer quiet luxury and 21st-century amenities, including individually zoned heating and cooling in every room, radiant-heated floors, a sprinkler system, 16-zone Sonos audio, an all-new Crestron security system, and exterior security cameras.

On the garden level, separate retail space is paired with a rear home office and a powder room. Through a pair of French doors, step out into the landscaped private garden. Bluestone pavers host a built-in Wolf grill. From here, access the home’s carriage house.

This charming outbuilding has a dramatic cathedral ceiling above vertical-grain Douglas fir paneling, its own heating and cooling system, and a sleeping loft.

The parlor floor begins with a suitably grand living room framed by herringbone-patterned oak floors and a fireplace. A sprawling, sun-filled eat-in kitchen overlooks the garden, anchored by a seating island. Custom cabinetry frames a suite of hard-working appliances by Wolf, Sub-Zero, Miele, and Gaggenau. Adjacent to the kitchen is a spacious formal dining room. A powder room serves this floor as well.

On the third floor, a lounge opens beneath 12-foot-high coffered ceilings. Highlights include a wood-burning fireplace and a terrace overlooking the garden and carriage house.

A pair of bedroom suites have en-suite baths, the larger with a fireplace. The smaller chamber has a sleeping loft. A fully-equipped laundry room completes this level. On the fourth floor are two more bedroom suites. Each has an en-suite bath and a study/office area.

The skylit primary suite occupies the entire fifth floor. The bedroom and adjacent sitting room open onto a private terrace overlooking the garden far below. A windowed dressing room sits adjacent a luxurious bathroom with a deep soaking tub, spa shower, and enclosed water closet with a toilet and bidet.

Atop the townhouse, a skylit private fitness and wellness loft awaits morning workouts. An unfinished roof terrace provides neighborhood views from far above.

[Listing details: 168 East 91st Street at CityRealty]

[At Brown Harris Stevens by Daniella G. Schlisser and Justin J. Pak]

RELATED:

All photos courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens

Get Inspired by NYC.

Interested in seeing the property in person?

It’s free, with no obligation.

CityRealty Logo

Distinctive Post Form

"*" indicates required fields

All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer and for no listing shall the number of bedrooms listed be considered a legal conclusion.

You May Also Like