24 Middagh Street

Townhouse in Brooklyn Heights

View the CityRealty Profile of 24 Middagh Street

All photos courtesy of Allyson Lubow for The Corcoran Group

July 8, 2022

Brooklyn Heights’ oldest home is back on the market with refreshed interiors for $4.25M

By Devin Gannon

The oldest home in Brooklyn Heights is once again for sale, following an update to its interiors. The history of the Federal-style corner property at 24 Middagh Street is fuzzy, but reports date the home's construction between 1790 and 1829. The five-bedroom home, which also includes a separate two-story carriage house and a private courtyard, was last on the market in 2018 for $4,500,000; it is currently listed for $4,250,000.
Take a look inside

September 4, 2018

Brooklyn Heights’ oldest home returns to the market after a $2M price chop

By Devin Gannon

Owning a piece of New York City history just got a little cheaper. The oldest home in Brooklyn Heights, located at 24 Middagh Street, has hit the market again, this time asking $4.5 million, a price drop of over $2 million from when it was listed last year. The five-bedroom Federal-style home boasts a private, landscaped courtyard and a separate two-bedroom carriage house.
Enough of a discount?

February 22, 2017

Oldest home in Brooklyn Heights is on the market for $6.65M

By Dana Schulz

Built in 1824, 24 Middagh Street is a charming, wood-frame, Federal house in Brooklyn Heights that has the distinction of being the oldest home in the neighborhood. And it's just gotten a price chop to $6,650,000 (it first listed this past September for the first time in nearly 60 years, asking $7 million). The listing says most of the original interior details--like wood floors, fireplaces, and moldings--are intact, and the five-bedroom residence even comes with a landscaped backyard and separate, two-bedroom carriage house.
More on the home this way

Interested in seeing the property in person?

It’s free, with no obligation.

"*" indicates required fields

or Call (212) 755-5544

24 Middagh Street

Brooklyn Heights’ oldest home is back on the market with refreshed interiors for $4.25M

Brooklyn Heights’ oldest home returns to the market after a $2M price chop

Oldest home in Brooklyn Heights is on the market for $6.65M

Interested in seeing the property in person?

Pitch a Story

Interested in seeing the property in person?

Distinctive Post Form

Share with your friends!

Get in Touch

Send us a Tip

Interesting in learning more about purchasing a new home?

Thinking about selling your home?

Sell a Home (Footer)

Before You Move On from this Page.

Your Passport to NYC:Subscribe for Local Insights and Stories!

Before You Move On
from this Page.

Your Passport to NYC:
Subscribe for Local Insights and Stories!